The LipidWeb blank

Mass Spectrometry of 3-Pyridylcarbinol Esters

Cyclic Fatty Acids

This document does not aim to be a complete account of mass spectrometry with electron-impact ionization of naturally occurring fatty acids containing ring structures as the 3-pyridylcarbinol ('picolinyl') esters, but rather is a personal account of our experience of those encountered during our research activities and for which we have spectra available for illustration purposes. Spectra of these fatty acids for methyl esters and DMOX derivatives with pyrrolidides are described in separate documents. Where we are aware of prior illustrations of mass spectra in the literature, the appropriate papers are cited. These notes are intended as a practical guide rather than as a mechanistic account, but our web page on mass spectrometry of 3-pyridylcarbinol esters of saturated fatty acids contains more introductory and mechanistic information, together with links to pages dealing with additional practical methodology (sample concentration, derivative preparation, etc) The occurrence and biological properties of cyclic fatty acids have been reviewed by Sébédio and Grandgirard (1989). In addition, there is further information on the chemistry, occurrence and biochemistry of cyclic fatty acids on this website here...

Cyclopropyl Fatty Acids

Cyclopropyl fatty acids are common constituents of bacterial lipids and may accompany cyclopropene fatty acids as minor components of certain seed oils. 3-Pyridylcarbinol esters are by far the most useful derivatives for characterization of fatty acids with cyclopropane rings, as they give distinctive cleavages that permit facile location of the ring in the alkyl chain. As an example, the mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 9,10-methylene-octadecanoate is illustrated.

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 9,10-methylene-octadecanoate

There are the usual ions in the lower molecular weight region at m/z = 92, 108, 151 and 164, typical of a 3-pyridylcarbinol ester, but the [M‑1]+ ion is more abundant than the molecular ion (m/z = 387) itself. The distinctive ion that permits location of the ring is odd-numbered (uncommon) at m/z = 247, simplistically representing cleavage at the ring as shown (Harvey, 1984). Otherwise the homologous series of ions 14 amu apart from m/z = 372 down to 274 confirm that there are no unusual features between C10 and C17, while a comparable homologous series of ions in the early part of the spectrum is of similar value.

With methyl esters, and dimethyloxazoline and pyrrolidide derivatives of cyclopropyl fatty acids, the ring appears to rearrange under electron bombardment in the mass spectrometer so that spectra are similar to those of monoenoic fatty acids with an alkyl chain one carbon longer. While these can still be useful, 3-pyridylcarbinol derivatives are to be preferred. Alternative procedures use ring-opening methods prior to mass spectrometry (see our web page on methyl esters of cyclic fatty acids).

In the spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 11,12-methylene-octadecanoate (lactobacillic acid), illustrated next, the distinctive ion that locates the ring has shifted 28 amu as expected to m/z = 275.

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 11,12-methylene-octadecanoate

Cyclopropenyl Fatty Acids

It was long thought that gas chromatography (GC) and thus GC-MS of derivatives of cyclopropenyl fatty acids was impossible because of thermal degradation on the GC column. However, modern capillary columns are relatively inert, and analysis by GC is straightforward, provided that appropriate derivatization methods are employed, i.e. that acidic conditions are avoided.

The mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl sterculate (from the seed oil of Sterculia africana) is distinctive and is illustrated next (see Spitzer et al., 1994).

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl sterculate

In this instance, the diagnostic cleavages occur on either side of the ring and beta to it, giving distinctive ions at m/z = 220 and 286. There is also an ion that appears to be characteristic at m/z = 293 (though not found apparently by Spitzer et al, 1994), which has now been identified as containing the fatty acyl chain without the 3-pyridylcarbinyl moiety, i.e. it represents a distinctive type of fragmentation that appears to be unique to and diagnostic for cyclopropene rings (Knothe et al., 2011).

As might be expected, the analogous diagnostic ions in the mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl malvalate (8,9-methylene-heptadec-8-enoate) are all 14 amu lower.

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl malvalate

ω-Cyclopentenyl and Cyclopentyl Fatty Acids

Fatty acids with a terminal cyclopent-2-enyl moiety are found in high concentration in the seed oils of several species from the plant family Flacourtiaceae, though the corresponding cyclopentyl (saturated species) have been detected at low levels only.

In my opinion, 3-pyridylcarbinol esters are by far the best for characterization of fatty acids with cyclopentenyl and cyclopentyl moieties, especially when these are on the terminal or ω-carbon of the aliphatic chain (Christie et al., 1989). For example, the mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 11-cyclopentylundecanoate is illustrated next -

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 11-cyclopentylundecanoate

In the high mass region, the molecular ion (at m/z = 345) is followed by a relatively clear gap of 69 amu to an ion at m/z = 276, representing loss of the cyclopentane ring. Thereafter, there is a regular series of ions 14 amu part for cleavage at the successive methylene groups. The ion for the charged cyclopentane ring (m/z = 69) is also distinctive.

Similarly, 3-pyridylcarbinol esters work best with cyclopentenyl fatty acids, as illustrated with the mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl hydnocarpate (11-cyclopentenylundecanoate) -

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl hydnocarpate

Here the gap of 67 amu between the molecular ion and that at m/z = 276 is clearly diagnostic for loss of the cyclopentene ring, while the ionized cyclopentene ring (m/z = 67) is in fact the base ion.

Three main isomers with one double bond in the chain are also found in nature and the only isomer where identification might be problematic is 3-pyridylcarbinyl 13-cyclopent-2-enyltridec-4-enoate -

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 13-cyclopent-2-enyltridec-4-enoate

The cyclopentene ring is located by the gap of 67 amu in the high mass region of the spectrum as before. The double bond in position 4 is recognized by the fingerprint ions at m/z = 205 and 218, together with the ion at m/z = 164 of low intensity relative to that at m/z = 151 (see the original reference (Christie et al., 1989) or the section of the mass spectrometry pages on 3-pyridylcarbinol esters of monoenes. There is obviously no double bond between carbons 6 and 13 as can be determined from the regular series of ions 14 amu apart from m/z = 218 to 302.

Similarly, with 3-pyridylcarbinyl 15-cyclopent-2-enylpentadec-9-enoate or hormelate (next spectrum), the ions for the cyclopropene ring and its loss are highly characteristic, and the position of the double bond in position 9 can be stated with absolute certainty from a knowledge of the spectra of the appropriate monoene standards.

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 15-cyclopent-2-enylpentadec-9-enoate

ω-Phenyl Fatty Acids

Fatty acids with a terminal phenyl moiety are found in seed oils of the subfamily Aroideae of the Araceae and certain species of bacteria. Some of the available data have been published (Christie, 2003).

3-Pyridylcarbinyl 13-phenyl-tridecanoate has the mass spectrum illustrated next. The distinctive and diagnostic feature is a gap of 91 amu between m/z = 290 and 381 (M+) for loss of the terminal phenyl group together with carbon-13, presumably as the stable tropylium ion (see our web page on the methyl ester derivatives of these fatty acids for a discussion). Thereafter, there are sequential gaps of 14 amu for loss of successive methylene groups in the aliphatic chain. The tropylium ion per se is the base peak.

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 13-phenyl-tridecanoate

Spectra of further homologues have recently been published (Schröder, M. et al., 2014).

When there is a further double bond in the alkyl chain, it can be located in a relatively straight-forward manner with 3-pyridylcarbinol esters. For example, the mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 15-phenyl-pentadec-9-enoate is –

Mass spectrum of 3-pyridylcarbinyl 15-phenyl-pentadec-9-enoate

In addition to the ions that locate the phenyl moiety, the position of the double bond in the alkyl chain is easily determined from the ions highlighted (see our web page on the 3-pyridylcarbinol derivatives of monoenes for a detailed explanation, as for that of the hormelate derivative above).

There are mass spectra of 3-pyridylcarbinol esters of many more cyclic fatty acids in our Archive section, but without interpretation.

Cyclic Fatty Acids Formed in Frying Oils

Fatty acids with internal five- and six-membered ring structures are formed when vegetable oils are heated to the high temperatures attained during frying or the physical refining process. The mechanism of cyclization is now believed to involve concerted thermal rearrangements with loss of one of the double bonds. As a host of basic structures can be formed from different fatty acid precursors, and cis-trans isomerization of double bonds and/or about the ring also takes place, the range of cyclic products is very great. With my colleagues and collaborators, we have characterized most of these with the aid of both 3-pyridylcarbinol esters and dimethyloxazoline derivatives, and of course others have worked on the problem (see Christie and Dobson, 2000). However, this is too specialized a topic for further discussion here.


I also recommend - Christie, W.W. and Han, X. Lipid Analysis - Isolation, Separation, Identification and Lipidomic Analysis (4th edition), 446 pages (Oily Press, Woodhead Publishing and now Elsevier) (2010) - at Science Direct.

Credits/disclaimer Updated: October 5th, 2018 Author: William W. Christie LipidWeb icon